Sunday, January 23, 2011

Herding or Tunneling

Humans have a tendency to tunnel which is also known as "herding".

If given the task to predict a certain event and give a number or date on when a certain event would happen, then most people would guess close to each other than close to the actual number. Even complicated financial models are used but the results are always herded close together. If economists are asked to predict the GDP growth rate next year, then everyone would give very similar numbers which would in general be very far from the actual number.

Herding or tunneling is specifically dangerous in extremistan where there are large deviations.

http://www.math.nyu.edu/fellows_fin_math/gatheral/extremistan.pdf

http://www.soa.org/library/newsletters/risk-management-newsletter/2010/march/jrm-2010-iss18-mills.pdf


Expert Tunneling
A second extremely dangerous idea is "expert tunnelling". Experts tend to tunnel more precisely with an even smaller standard deviation.

If a taxi driver is asked to predict tomorrow's weather than he'll predict it with a wide standard deviation. On the other hand, a weather expert would have a very small standard deviation and more confidence in his predictions. The weather expert would suffer more from unexpected and large deviations compared to a taxi driver who would not rely on his prediction and would consider worst case scenarios.

Tunneling is dangerous when you try to predict complicated phenomenon that are inherently unpredictable, or which are only predictable for some time and become unpredictable later on. 

Saturday, January 22, 2011

Animals in Captivity vs Humans in Captivity

I went through an interesting article which described different ill effects of keeping animal sin captivity.  The article is copied below. One interesting observation was that the quality of off springs starts to degrade and the familial bonds start to break since they are not important and are not needed.

Plus Intelligence and instincts degrade because there is no longer enough variety.


Animals in Captivity vs.
Animals in the Wild
   
Kah Ying Choo
     
One of the key problems with placinganimals in captivity is the fact that the typical development of their authentic being is arrested at all levels.  Although scientists working with animals in captivity claim that the needs of these creatures are satisfied, they have failed to acknowledge the adverse impact of the deficiencies of the physical and social environment on the quality of life of these animals.  
    
For example, orcas and dolphins in thewild exhibit high intelligence, a strong need for social interaction and intense activity.  The challenging environment in the ocean propels them to exercise their physical and mental
prowess constantly.   In contrast, the typical physical and mental activity of dolphins in aquariums is limited by the static quality of the environment and the size of the tanks.  Essentially, the orcas and dolphins are living in prisons (Animal Protection Institute, 2000, p. 1).

Another negative side-effect associated with the physical environmentprovided to dolphins in captivity has been found in the study of echolocation in captivity.  Unlike the ocean that has softer sounds covering a wider bandwidth, dolphins in captivity often become deaf when they are exposed to the excessive concentration of sounds in the aquariums.  Concomitantly, their ability to function normally is also affected (Ellis, 1982; Harrison et al., 1994).

Moreover, animals in the wild such as dolphins and orcas co-exist indistinctive groups and forge strong and enduring bonds with one another, which can last for as long as ten years.  Within each of these groups, or pods, the family members communicate with one another with their own unique vocalizations.  On the other hand, in captivity, the development of social organizations among the dolphins is undermined by the fact that family members can be traded and sold to other aquariums.   Some dolphins are separated from their mothers when they are only six months old, thus preventing them from experiencing a typical social life (Animal Protection Institute, 2000, p. 1).   In addition, different species of dolphins that have different social organizations and habits are restricted to the choice of their tank mates without the possibility of seeking out members of their own species.

Without the opportunity to learn social organizations and habits, manyanimals in captivity are unable to nurture or care for the young.  In the case of chimpanzees, wild female chimps acquire their nurturing skills from their mothers and other female relatives within their social group.  However, young chimps that have grown up in captivity do not have the opportunities to learn from their wild-born relatives.   More adapted to human ways, these female chimps have lost their natural propensity and skills to care for their own young (Rock, 1995, p. 71).
Therefore, animals in captivity are affectedby extreme boredom, lack of appropriate exercise, poor quality food and a lack of variety of food, especially in poorly run facilities.  Since the development of their natural instincts and typical behavior has been stifled prematurely, animals in captivity that are released are unable to function normally in the wild.  Animals in captivity that are used to being fed with dead fish and meat by trainers are unable to eat live fish.

Unaware of the social organization that exist in the wild, dolphins and orcas that attempt to join pods of animals of a different species are often attacked.   In fact, the mortality rate of the released captive animals is 15 percent (Ellis, 1982; Harrison et al., 1994).  While this fact can be used to support the captivity of animals, it
testifies to the tragedy of animals in captivity, which have lost their connection to their authentic being and identity at every level.

Because they are deprived of their natural environment, social interaction and typical activity, animals in captivity often divert their energies and anxiety into stereotypical behavior that are not evident in animals in the wild (Animal Protection Institute, 2000, p. 2).   For example, tigers in the wild typically spend ten hours of the day hunting and monitoring their territory.   However, their circus counterparts that are unable to perform these activities are forced to replace the typical physical activity by pacing their cages in order to release their energy.   In their study, Nevill and Friend discovered that only by providing circus tigers with opportunities for exercise did the amount of pacing decrease (cited in Chenault, 2002, p. 2).
The above discussion has illuminated the tragic consequences ofsuppressing the typical development of animals by placing them in captivity.  Deprived of their natural environment and social groupings, these creatures are unable to learn in a way that will help them achieve their full potential and realize their authentic being.   Instead, their natural activity is transformed into stereotypical behavior such as the tigers’ pacing of their cages or unpredictable eruptions of aggression by circus elephants.   I believe these concepts can be extrapolated to young school children who are trapped not only within the physical confines of the school classroom, but also its oppressive rules and expectations, thus preventing them from achieving their human potential.
References
Animal Protection Institute (2000, April).  Serving a life sentence: orcas and dolphins in captivity. Retrieved August 19, 2002, from http://www.api4animals.org/doc.asp?ID=300&print=y
Chenault, E. A. (2002, July 2).  Hold that tiger: research studies circus tigers’ behavior, environment. AgNews.  Retrieved August 19, 2002, from http://agnews.tamu.edu/dailynews/stories/ANSC/Jul0202a.htm
Ellis, R. (1982).  Dolphins and porpoises.  New York: Alfred & Knopf, Inc.
Harrison, R., et al. (1994).  Whales, dolphins and porpoises.  New York: Facts on File, Inc.
Rock, M. (1995, March).  Human ‘moms’ teach chimps it’s all in the family.  Smithsonian, 25(12), 70-75.

Wednesday, January 19, 2011

Edith Piaf



Non, Je Ne Regrette Rien


Ne Me Quitte Pas

Tuesday, January 18, 2011

Jacques Brel's Brilliance


Some of the most awesome works of Jacques Brel

Don't Leave Me


Amsterdam

Sunday, January 16, 2011

Aesthetics: Robert Hopkins

Robert Hopkins has written extensively on Aesthetics and Belief. He is the head of department at University of Sheffield.

http://www.shef.ac.uk/philosophy/research/publications/hopkinsr.html

Here is one research paper written by him on Aesthetics and Belief:
http://www.british-aesthetics.org/uploads/Hopkins%20final.pdf

Here's another excellent paper on critical reasoning and aesthetics, where he points out that critical reasoning engenders perceptions and is not useful for the formation of beliefs:
http://eprints.whiterose.ac.uk/10337/1/Critical_Reasoning_%26_Critical_Perception.pdf

Aesthetics and Belief


Read original here
I wanted to write on this subject, but instead found a very useful post on this subject. My contention was that "CAN AESTHETICS BE DEVOID OF BELIEF"

Years ago, I came to the quiet decision that the god I was introduced to at an early age in Sunday school was no longer a god I wanted to believe in.  He had become an ugly and vengeful being. And though I still participated and the day to day Christian activities of the bible college town we were living in at the time, I knew that this “god” that I had either been overtly taught or inadvertently inferred to through the hidden curriculum of this particular institution was dead to me.  I didn’t become an atheist (in the practical sense - I'm far too non-confrontational), though I could certainly see the attraction. 
But things changed after some time.  I was re-introduced to the God who had been lost in the hierarchies and patriarchies of my past church experiences.   This is the God who is beautiful. The words in the bible didn’t change.  The church didn’t really change.  The evidence didn’t change. What changed was the aesthetic… I was gently and graciously discipled into recognizing what was beautiful and what was ugly through the lens of Christ.  I was working with largely the same materials, but yet I saw things so differently. 
The question could be asked what makes the difference between loving Christians and Christians who are full of bitterness and hatred?  What makes a Mother Theresa and what makes a Pat Robertson?  They accept similar concepts as true.  They read the same scriptures and both are integrated into a largely imperfect institutional church, yet their outcomes – their actions – are vastly different.  Their actions, or as some might argue their true beliefs, are governed by a sense of what is beautiful and what is ugly.  If I find the story of a god who demands blood and sacrifice and whose justice takes its truest form in smiting those who oppose him (which could easily be a rational interpretation of many passages in the Old Testament) a beautiful story, then my actions and likewise my true belief system, will reflect this.  However, if I am uncomfortable with this interpretation and instead look at scripture through the aesthetic lens of the story of Christ, God’s justice becomes something entirely different.  
“Evidence”, whatever we define that to be (the words of scripture or of religious authorities, or observable scientific evidence or even personal experience), should never be our only basis of belief… Evidence alone can lead us down dark paths.  Instead, we see evidence through an aesthetic lens from which we determine things as beautiful or ugly, acceptable or unacceptable. If the evidence we hold as most important points us in an ugly direction, we might consciously re-evaluate and search for alternatives.   We are convinced to a certain degree by what aesthetic is most pleasing to us before we even consider the evidence.   
Scientifically, one could argue that the genetic differences between certain animals and humans are so miniscule that it there is no reason humans (especially humans who don’t possess the abilities, either because of age or mental deficiency, from which we tend to define our “humanness”) should be treated no differently than animals – to be used and then to be put down when rendered useless.  Of course even those who argue from this point of view most likely do not live out these concepts (though there are those who have), not because the evidence does not support such a conclusion, but because the conclusion is so very horrific.  The horror and the ugliness of such a claim prevents it from finding its way (fingers crossed) into the mainstream.  We weigh the aesthetics of the conclusions of such a claim, and then move from the evidence (which exists and has credibility in this case) to an interpretation, to a belief, to a way of life.  Perhaps in a debate on the subject, it wouldn't be a game-ender to simply argue "That's just ugly".  But for most of us I think the supreme ugliness of culling the sick and the elderly would far outweigh any argument, no matter how well corroborated it might be (I say this as a hopeful person). 
I suppose some might think the idea that preferences of beauty and ugliness shape what we accept as true sounds wobbly at best.  In our culture we’re so used to understanding beauty as something purely superficial or material, or something that can only be defined in the eye of the beholder.   It is at least somewhat individual, yes.  But the idea that because aesthetics has a subjective element and therefore has no authority is a modern myth, one that divorces us from our histories, cultures and all those things that bond us together as human beings.  It could be argued that most of the dilemmas Western culture faces today stem from an inability either to recognize beauty or to recognize the importance of beauty.
What do we mean to say when we speak of someone who is “rational” or “wise”?  Do we mean to say this person is adept at carefully sorting through and weighing the data in order to ascertain what is true and what is not?  Certainly this is part of the answer.  But one who is wise and prudent, no matter what he or she might claim as belief or disbelief, is one whose aesthetic lens is finely tuned to recognize the beautiful and the ugly.   
May I aspire to be such a person – one whose beliefs do not start and stop at demanding evidence, but one who can also see and hear the beautiful.

Saturday, January 15, 2011

Are minorities primed to Succeed?

Given equal chances, why are minorities much more successful compared to the majority.


  • Jews in America
  • Protestants in France
  • Arab Christians in the Arab World
  • Shia minority sects in Pakistan
Vice versa, there are those that were not successful, mainly due to persecution such as, jews in europe, indian muslims etc.