Showing posts with label pashtunwali. Show all posts
Showing posts with label pashtunwali. Show all posts

Thursday, April 7, 2011

Enemies and Friends - Pashtunwali and Modernity

It is a very dehumanizing experience to sit with people or be around people that one hates and dislikes. Office/work life is all about struggling to cope with emotions like hate which one often feels towards his fellow colleagues and bosses. Humans are not made to fit cubicles inside offices that look like cubicles etc. We have evolved to live in a different world all together, a world where enemies are enemies and friends are friends. Modern life has blurred this definition of friendship and animosity. It's actually beneficial in a modern work place to be friends with your enemies, not showing your inner emotions to your closest enemies.

Now the problem with hiding emotions is that it is chronic. And this happens day in and day out and goes non-stop. People rarely fight in offices, and once too often we hear of people completely going nuts breaking stuff with some of their friends (disguised enemies) uploading their youtube videos and making them and instant hit.

I was reading on pashtunwali and thinking about this difference between modern and ancient heuristics about friendship and enmity.

Modern heuristics on enmity:


1) Treat your enemies as your friends, call them once in a while, go and meet them and act friendly towards them, go out of your way to make sure that your inner emotions are always hidden.

2) Be even more friendly to your enemy than your closest friends if there is a reward at the end of the tunnel

3) Your friends wouldn't really be sure if they truly are friends because friendship/enmity signalling is so mixed up. You would most likely have no real friends and the people you think are your friends may actually be your enemies.

4) Be chronically stressed about your relationships




Ancient Pashtun heuristics



  • Melmastia (hospitality) - Showing hospitality and profound respect to all visitors, regardless of distinctions of race, religion, national affiliation as well as economic status and doing so without any hope of remuneration or favour. Pashtuns are considered to be the most hospitable people in the world. A Pashtun may go to great lengths to show his hospitality.[4][14][15]

  • Nanawatai (asylum) - Derived from the verb meaning to go in, this is used for protection given to a person who requests protection against his/her enemies. The people are protected at all costs, in many cases even people running from the law must be given refuge until the situation is clarified.[4] It can also be used when the vanquished party is prepared to go in to the house of the victors and ask for their forgiveness. (Is a peculiar form of "chivalrous" surrender, in which an enemy seeks "sanctuary" at his enemy's house).

  • Badal (justice) - To seek justice or take revenge against the wrongdoer. This applies to injustices committed yesterday or 1000 years ago if the wrongdoer still exists. Justice in Pashtun lore needs elaborating: even a mere taunt (or "Paighor") is regarded as an insult - often, shedding the taunter's blood is the only acceptable redress (and if he isn't available, then his next closest male relation). This in turn may lead to a blood feud that can last generations and involve whole tribes with the loss of hundreds of lives.[4]

  • Tureh (bravery) - A Pashtun must defend his land/property, family and women from incursions wherever he or she might reside. A Pashtun should always stand brave against tyranny and he should always be able to defend his property, family, women and the honour of his name; killing the offending party is an acceptable recourse for an attack on any of these.[4]

  • Sabat (loyalty) - Loyalty must be paid to one's family, friends, and tribe members. Disloyalty is extremely shameful in Pashtun culture, and a Pashtun's family, friends, and tribe members are also shamed if one is disloyal.

  • Imandari (righteousness) - A Pashtun must always strive towards thinking good thoughts, speaking good words and doing other good deeds. Pashtuns must behave respectfully towards all creations including people, animals and the environment around them. Pollution of the environment or its destruction is against the Pashtunwali.[4]

  • Isteqamat - Trust in God (known as "Allah" in Arabic and "Khudai-ta-Allah" in Pashto).[4] The notion of trusting in the one Creator generally comports to Islamic belief in only one God (tawheed).

  • Ghayrat (self honour or dignity) - Pashtuns must maintain their human dignity. Honour has great importance in Pashtun society and most other codes of life are aimed towards the preservation of one's honour or pride. They must respect themselves and others in order to be able to do so, especially those they do not know. Respect begins at home, among family members and relatives.[4]

  • Namus (Honor of women) - A Pashtun must defend the honor of Pashtun women at all costs and must protect them from verbal and physical harm.[4]

    Not all apply to enmity and friendship but here is the crux of the matter.


    In pashtunwali, you treat your enemy in the worst possible manner (revenge is compulsory) but when he seeks hospitality/help or asylum from you then its your duty to take care of him even if your own family goes hungry. In pashtun culture, the enemies house is the best place to seek help when one is in trouble.

    In modern times, it's the opposite, you treat your enemy as your friend but when he seeks hospitality/help or asylum, you hesitate to offer it, which is a weaker form of revenge and far worse.


  • Tuesday, November 23, 2010

    Pashtunwali and Modernity

    NATGEO's jailed abroad episode on Pakistan should be an inspiration to anyone who thinks that Pashtun tribes are backward and that their tribal code (pashtunwali) is archaic and inhuman. Modern world has long given up on honor, dignity and character. It produces people like Bernie Madoff who robs people and still manages to keep a smile on his face. This episode reminds me off Samurai warriors who would cut themselves up when they were dishonored.

    Here's the link to a short promo to the episode:
    http://channel.nationalgeographic.com/series/locked-up-abroad/3807/Videos#tab-Videos/05770_00

    A better review was written of the episode and is posted below



    Our "enemies" can be inspirational, compassionate, and teach us valuable lessons.

    I recently watched an episode of National Geographic’s program, “Locked Up Abroad”, specifically an episode titled “Pakistan”. I would definitely check your listings and see when it airs next in your area. I can’t find the entire episode on YouTube, and the summary that NatGeo posted does not do justice to the real human story (one I doubt they intended for the series). But here is my brief summary if you don’t have cable / NatGeo.
    Amardeep Bassey, a British journalist of Indian and Afghan descent, was working for his English newspaper in Islamabad, Pakistan in 2002. In early May 2002, he was placed on assignment to head into Kabul and report on the real pulse of the Afghan citizens in the wake of the American-led war.
    He made contact with Tariq Khan in Peshawar, northwest Pakistan, in order to begin arranging his trip to Kabul. Tariq was an aid worker (human rights commission) and a well-known contact for journalists traveling in the region. Amardeep expressed his concern for safety; Tariq then suggested he could have one of his friends or relatives tag along for the journey. Everything was agreed upon, and the journey began.
    In order to reach Afghanistan, Amardeep would need to cross Pakistan’s tribal areas and their six million inhabitants, which are dominated by fiercely independent tribal chieftains. The checkpoint where Peshawar ends and the tribal areas begin are clearly marked with signs such as “No foreigners beyond this point”, and this is where Tariq got out of the taxi and let Amardeep continue on..
    Amardeep arrived in a town within the tribal areas to meet his arranged escort, Noushad Ali Afridi. Noushad was a relative of Tariq Khan and a son of a powerful tribal leader. When Noushad finally arrived, he and Amardeep sat down and got to business, talking about what the journalistic intentions were.. After a short talk, each got the impression the other was “OK” and essentially gave each other their word they would both head to Kabul together.
    The next day, Amardeep was dressed head-to-toe in Muslim clothing in order to blend in. It is worth noting that Amardeep is a Sikh, a religion with roots in 15th-century India. Sikhism is not compatible with Islamic views, and as we all know, Pakistan and India have never had the friendliest relations. As a Sikh, Amardeep had on a silver bracelet placed on him when he was a child, and these things don’t come off because you grow into them and your wrist becomes too big for the thing to come off. This becomes important later…
    Everything works out; they cross the porous border very easily, get into Kabul, and over the next day complete their interviews. It is now time to head back. They catch some transportation to the border, and upon crossing Amardeep goes through Pakistani passport control. Turns out his visa was not valid for multiple entries (Amardeep knew this ahead of time, but was told it could be sorted out at the passport office). Long story made short, he was detained for interrogation at the border.
    During the interrogation, he was accused of being an Indian spy, as there were heightened tensions between India and Pakistan at the time. His notebooks of interviews with Afghan citizens were written in shorthand (a journalistic way of capturing data quickly) and it was assumed this was some kind of “spy code”. They also assumed the British passport was a forgery, and told Amardeep he was going to jail for being a spy.
    This is where the story gets really interesting. The Pakistani intelligence officer informs Amardeep he is being sent for “processing” (jail), and informs Noushad he is free to go. Noushad, having known Amardeep for only 48 hours or so, refuses to leave. He simply tells the intelligence officer, “I am going with him (Amardeep)”. Amardeep is as taken aback at this as the intelligence officer, since Noushad has not been charged with anything. The intelligence officer asks Noushad to reconsider, but Noushad simply replies with “Pashtunwali”. Pashtunwali is a code of honor, in which you offer protection for someone, regardless of religion, nationality, or background. Because of this code of honor, Noushad links his fate to that of Amardeep’s, and informs the intelligence officer he must accompany Amardeep to prison.
    Let’s review the situation for a second. Noushad is the son of a prominent Pakistani tribal leader. Pakistan is a Muslim country, and has been in a perpetual state of strife with India since its inception as a country. Amardeep is a Sikh, and even worse a British (westerner) Sikh. Here we have two absolutely sworn enemies, basically a steroid version of Montague/Capulet, and Noushad having only known Amardeep for 48 hours will still commit himself to the same fate in the name of selfless honor.
    Once again, long story short, after several months bouncing between prisons and interrogation facilities, Amardeep is finally released. Noushad is not. Amardeep is torn to friggin pieces, here is someone who stuck up for him, helped him within the different jails & prisons, and went through all of this torment based on “My WORD is my BOND”. If you want to know the heart-warming end of the story (it involves a meeting in 2008, 6 years after all this went down), go watch this show or have someone you know YouTube it.
    We Westerners are so distanced from this kind of honor and dignity. We sign contracts because we need assurances we won’t be fu**ed down the road. We keep receipts so that we can return that blender after it fails to chop ice in the way we had imagined. We wrap ourselves into a massive blanket of “cover-your-ass” paperwork and procedure to the point someone’s word is worth nothing unless legalized, documented, and signed in triplicate. I don’t think anyone I have known for 48 hours in the western societies would go to third-world prisons and interrogation sessions just based on their word, especially if they were told several times “you are free to go….”
    I am not saying we can change the system; it is all too far gone for that. I will sign contracts, keep receipts, and make sure I “cover my ass” moving through life in this “honorable western world”. I am simply saying we can take a lesson from those our system calls “backwards”, “archaic”, or as more commonly known, “enemies of freedom”.