Showing posts with label person::amotz zahavi. Show all posts
Showing posts with label person::amotz zahavi. Show all posts

Monday, November 15, 2010

Humans and Signaling: Pride and Status

Signalling is an important trait and reflects one's social status. The following are some important factors that affect one's perceived status in society.

  • miserliness
  • altruism
  • hard work
  • sports
  • being well dressed
  • shave daily
  • muscular physique
Since signalling according to Zahavi is costly and is inherently a handicap hence one must fake some of the signals as effectively as possible. Always hide your miserliness and appear to be altruistic. Never appear to be working hard but being more productive and by hiding the effort required. Being good at sports is another effective signal of status, but efforts must be hidden as this would further increased perceived status.

"Only in recent history has "working hard" signaled pride rather than shame for lack of talent, finesse &, mostly, sprezzatura", Nassim Taleb

Monday, November 8, 2010

Understanding Risk using the "Handicap Principle"

When it comes to evolution, survival of the fittest is only half the story. The handicap principle holds that humans make showy and sometimes dangerous displays of courage to increase their status and attract mates.

Two thirds of the way into his August 1998 attempt to fly round the world by balloon, Steve Fossett ran into a thunderstorm at 29,000 feet above the Coral Sea and began to plunge uncontrollably as wind and hail whipped his ruptured balloon. At 4,000 feet, he climbed through the hatch atop his capsule and cut away the fuel and oxygen tanks to slow the descent. Then he lay down on a bench to distribute the impending impact across his back. "I'm going to die," he said out loud.

I'd met Fossett the year before, and he was mild and Midwestern, a multimillionaire with no particular need for publicity. Now he was falling out of the sky in a broken balloon. Why? For that matter, why did another American businessman recently pay $20 million to get himself launched into space on a Russian rocket? Why do ordinary people climb Mount Everest?

Risky behavior might seem like just a quirk of the oddly named species Homo sapiens, except that a taste for grandstanding is common in the natural world too. For instance, antelope pursued by hungry cheetahs often leap acrobatically straight into the air, a practice called stotting. Common sense says they should be sprinting straight for the far horizon. Even lowly guppies dance right under a predator's nose before darting away. Why do humans and animals alike do such dumb stuff? Stuff that is unnecessary, flamboyant, and often downright deadly?

In search of answers, I found myself at five o'clock one recent morning rattling across an Israeli desert in a dusty little Peugeot with Amotz Zahavi, the 73-year-old bete noire of the biological world. "This is a minefield," Zahavi said, indicating a fenced-off area just to our left. He veered right, both hands on the wheel, down into a wadi, or dry riverbed. "So we won't go there." We were looking for Arabian babblers, birds he has been studying for 30 years at the Hatzeva Field Station near the Jordanian border. The babblers, when we found the first group a few minutes later, were brownish, forward-leaning birds, about the size of mockingbirds, with long tails and sleek heads. Unflamboyant. Not, at first glance, worth the trip. But Zahavi introduced them as old friends, with names corresponding to the letters on their ankle bands: Pusht (PVST), Taxas (TXXS), Tasha-Sham (TSSM), and so on. The birds also knew Zahavi. They gathered at his feet and cocked one eye up, waiting for him to toss a bread crumb or the occasional mealy worm.

As Zahavi fed them, he rattled off individual stories out of a Middle Eastern melodrama: A brother killed in a trap three months ago, a mother forced to become a refugee, an exiled stepsister, Zatash (ZTAS), who'd returned and pushed her way back into the group. He knew the birds better than most people know their human neighbors, better perhaps than the birds knew themselves. "Go and copulate, lady," he commanded at one point, a little vexed with one coy babbler. No aspect of their lives was too trivial for Zahavi to mull over. "You sit here in the desert and say, 'Why is it like this and not like that?'" he remarked as we huddled under an acacia one evening waiting for a group of babblers to come to roost. "Being alone in the desert, all these things creep in sooner or later."

One of the things that crept in during the early years of his research was the far-ranging and controversial idea for which he is best known. Zahavi's handicap principle attempts to explain why babblers risk their lives by yelling at predators, why peacocks carry splendid but cumbersome tails twice the length of their bodies, and even perhaps why Ted Turner gave $1 billion to the United Nations. Zahavi's handicap principle holds that animals and humans alike prosper not in spite of our riskiest and most extravagant behaviors but because of them. These behaviors are the way we advertise how prosperous, how fit, how fearless we are. And because the world is a jaded, cynical place, we have to incorporate a significant cost, or handicap, in our advertising to make it persuasive. Thus antelopes really are indulging in a dangerous waste of energy when they stot in front of a cheetah. But their willingness to risk it is how they tell the cheetah: "Don't even bother trying."
When Zahavi first proposed this idea in the 1970s, the biological establishment reacted as if something bad had gotten stuck in its throat. In the first edition of his book The Selfish Gene, Oxford evolutionist Richard Dawkins called Zahavi's handicap principle "maddeningly contrary," and he wrote, with a cadence and clarity rarely seen in scientific writing: "I do not believe this theory." Robert Trivers, a Rutgers University evolutionist, used to kid Zahavi that if you took his idea to the logical extreme, you'd end up with a bird where both sexes fly upside down to show each other how good they'd be if they were flying right side up.

It didn't help that Zahavi was himself maddeningly contrary. The standard scientific practice of testing ideas with mathematical models was alien to him. He hatched his ideas based on observation and intuition alone, and he tended to question the intelligence of those who failed to embrace his conclusions, including prominent scientists who had risen by more traditional routes. When I reminded him of Trivers's joke one day, Zahavi said, "But they do fly upside down," and proceeded to rattle off bird species in which somersaults and other inversions are part of the mating display.

As we moved from one babbler group to the next, Zahavi was clearly happiest when he was being provocative. He argued, for instance, that a baby screaming for attention at the nest is actually blackmailing its parents, in effect saying, "Fox, fox, come and eat me. My parents don't care." Children on the sidewalk screaming at an unresponsive parent do the same thing, he added, and this is why, when they run away, they often run toward danger rather than away from it. Suicide is also an instance of the handicap principle, he said, a bid for help that we take seriously in direct proportion to the individual's actual risk of death. Indeed, Zahavi's own conversation seemed like a prime instance of the handicap principle, a contra dance at the edge of the unlikely. He summed up his big idea in a phrase: "Something can be good because it's bad."

In spite of Zahavi himself, evidence for the handicap principle began to accumulate. One study showed that African wild dogs and hyenas in fact avoid animals that stot, apparently because nonstotters are easier to catch. More important, an Oxford biologist named Alan Grafen demonstrated with a mathematical model that the handicap principle made sense in evolutionary terms. In the second edition of his book, Dawkins grumbled about the possibility that "theories of almost limitless craziness can no longer be ruled out on commonsense grounds." But he added, "if Grafen is right—and I think he is—it might even necessitate a radical change in our entire outlook on the evolution of behavior."
In fact, Zahavi's principle addressed one of the central problems in evolutionary thinking. Charles Darwin is of course best known for his theory of evolution by natural selection. But in his 1872 book, The Descent of Man,he developed an equally important idea, largely ignored until the mid-20th century. Evolution by sexual selection holds that genetic change is also influenced by the ability to attract and win access to members of the opposite sex. The trouble with these two ideas is that they often seem to contradict each other.

Natural selection essentially means that nature weeds out unfavorable traits by killing individuals who display them. Thus an arctic fox with a red bull's-eye on his side would quickly end up in a polar bear's belly. Individuals with more favorable traits, such as plain white fur for camouflage in snow, tend to survive and reproduce.

But in most species, females control mating, and they often have an irresistible attraction to the male with the equivalent of the red bull's-eye on his side. That is, they seem to select males for traits that make them less likely to survive. In peacocks, for instance, a bigger tail requires the male to waste huge amounts of energy. It also inhibits his ability to fly and makes him more vulnerable to predators. The female's own drab coloration attests to her abiding faith in the value of camouflage. But she will nonetheless choose the male with the bigger, showier tail nearly every time. The natural world is full of females falling hard for stupid male display behavior, including bright feathers, big antlers, and bombastic courtship rituals. Then again, male sexual selection sometimes forces irrational displays on females too. Most men prefer women with large, cumbersome breasts, for instance, though small breasts are just as good for nursing babies. It is, says Zahavi, a handicap, a cost ancestral women undertook to display greater nutritional fitness in the form of visible body fat.

Given the ruthless efficiency of the natural world, how could such costly traits have evolved in the first place? The classic explanation enshrined in biology textbooks is the "runaway process," a variant on sexual-selection theory devised by the British mathematician R.A. Fisher. Let's say ancestral peacocks started out dull-eyed and unbushy-tailed. Then, through some minor genetic shift, a few females developed a random hankering for males with slightly longer tails. If this flourish happened to occur in bigger, better males, then females who chose them would probably rear more offspring. Longer tails would proliferate in males, and the preference for them in females. So far so good. But the conventional understanding of Fisher is that females soon come to focus single-mindedly on this trait, regardless of a male's overall quality. And thus begins the cycle of runaway one-upmanship: Over thousands of generations, the peacock's tail continually lengthens and spreads out until no self-respecting male can get a date without a huge fan rattling on his rear end. Natural selection steps back in to stop the runaway process at the point where the quest for better sexual ornamentation is attracting enough predators to kill the hapless males.

The trouble with this idea, a student of Zahavi's argued one day, is that sexual selection isn't that whimsical. In the real world, females rigorously test males to see if they will make good mates (and males of course test females, too, though perhaps less rigorously). As Zahavi thought about it, he came to think females would choose an exaggerated trait only as long as it reliably displays that the male would be a better mate. So what good does a huge tail do for a peacock? And why would Irish elk have developed antlers with a 12-foot span?

Zahavi came up with a theoretical answer, then confirmed it one day while watching his babblers. He was trying to figure out why the babblers kept shouting at a hawk, instead of just quietly hiding in a bush. "And then I realized, they are talking to the predator." They were taking on a handicap by revealing their presence to the hawk—;and they were advertising that a surprise ambush wasn't going to work. It convinced Zahavi that flamboyant handicaps—;the babblers' shouting, the peacock's tail, the elk's antlers—;actually serve a useful purpose: The same displays that attract females also discourage predators and rival males.

This was the basic idea Grafen refined into the language of theoretical mathematics. He started with the assumption that females could use handicaps as a gauge for selecting the fittest males. For example, the arctic fox with the red bull's-eye wouldn't survive a single winter unless he also happened to be incredibly quick or cunning. Then Grafen calculated the advantage to the daughters in inheriting greater fitness. Finally, he added in the advantage to the sons who get saddled with Dad's dumb displays but thus attract more females and scare off more rivals. Grafen fine-tuned his model so that sons actually express Dad's handicap displays only in proportion to their own physical abilities. Thus Dad may stot like a champion, but if Number Two Son lacks zip, he soon drops out of the evolutionary equation in the form of fast food. When Grafen put all these calculations together, his model showed that, over time, the handicap principle should result in more offspring.

Zahavi did not wait for this moment of vindication. He'd been sure of his idea from the start, and he had been busily extending the principle into every known corner of the universe. In particular, Zahavi argued that it explains the evolutionary puzzle of altruism. In the narrowest Darwinian terms, acts of charity make no sense. Giving away food or other resources represents an apparent reduction in Darwinian fitness, a loss in the donor's own ability to survive and reproduce. So altruism should long ago have disappeared from the gene pool. But seemingly selfless acts are commonplace in the human and natural worlds. Other biologists have tried to explain this awkward fact through mechanisms like kinship selection (the idea that it pays to get your nephew Louis a job because he's carrying a quarter of your genes into the next generation) and reciprocal altruism ("You scratch my back, I'll scratch yours"). But Zahavi looked at the question from a radically different angle.

In the desert one morning, Zahavi stood over his birds, fondly rattling off a nonstop narration of their every chirp and shimmy. He is a grandfatherly figure, with steel-gray hair brushed up willy-nilly, bushy eyebrows, pouched eyes, and a paunch stretching his blue T-shirt out over the top of his gray shorts. He often imitates his birds, drawing himself up, hands pinned to his chest like wings, and saying, "WEET-WEET-WEET," or slumping his shoulders to mutter a timorous "weet." The effect is comical. But Zahavi believes in truth in advertising. That is, a handicap display must correlate with real quality, and a bird can only give a threatening shout if its body is upright. So imitation is a means of understanding: "If you are good at it, you can decipher from the sound what is happening in the body of the signaler." And Zahavi is good. "He's one of those naturalists," says Robert Trivers, his friend and sometime adversary, "who, if he were made a babbler tomorrow, would know most of the right moves to make."

Zahavi tossed a bread crumb, and the recipient, Tasha-Sham, did not gobble it down. Instead, he flitted up onto a tree where the subordinate male, Pusht, had been doing sentinel duty. Pusht saw what was coming and slipped away. But Tasha-Sham followed him to the ground. Then he held up the prize morsel until Pusht dutifully begged like a nestling, mouth open, wings quivering with sham enthusiasm. Zahavi interpreted: "The dominant says, 'You'll take what I'm going to give you.'"

Despite the babblers' drab appearance, an almost obsessive concern with status seemed to color every aspect of their lives, and altruism was one of their favorite forms of showing it. Tasha-Sham announced his act of charity by lifting his beak and giving a special trill, like a socialite posing for an event photographer at the Red Cross Ball. Watching this sort of behavior, Zahavi concluded that there are no truly selfless acts. "Altruism is advertising," he said. It is a handicap display, an "unseen peacock's tail," a bid for prestige and status. Giving away resources may actually increase Darwinian fitness, Zahavi reasoned, because big donors typically attract more potential mates and discourage more potential adversaries. "I have turned the tables and said altruism isn't loss of fitness," he said, triumphantly, "it is a gain in social prestige."

Zahavi's triumph was, in fact, nearly total. His handicap principle has become so well accepted in the biological world that it risks being, in Alan Grafen's words, "too much of an orthodoxy." But Zahavi characteristically took his argument a step further, and trashed all the alternative theories. Ideas like kinship selection and reciprocal altruism simply miss the point, Zahavi said. And Darwin was narrow-minded to call it evolution by sexual selection, because handicap displays, or signals, aren't just about winning mates; they're also about scaring off rivals. He should have called it evolution by signal selection.

Having entered Amotz Zahavi's upside-down world, I began to see handicap displays everywhere—;for instance, in the strange saga of Steve Fossett, last seen plunging from the skies in his broken balloon. The Coral Sea crash did not kill him: When he came to, after momentarily blacking out, his capsule was upside down in the ocean, half full of water and with flaming propane starting to torch through the hull. He grabbed his emergency satellite rescue beacon, scrambled out into his rubber raft, and waited for the next 23 hours to be rescued. This past August, Fossett was at it again, his sixth unsuccessful around-the-world attempt ending just over the Andes Mountains. Was he driven, as a sports commentator might put it, by the restless human urge for adventure? Or was it a handicap display, a bid for status made even riskier, and thus more glorious, by Fossett's initial ignorance about ballooning?

Fossett first got the idea to balloon around the world during a visit to Paris. What did it, oddly, was a $250 scarf from Hermes depicting some of the great pioneers of aviation. Up to that point, he had never even ridden in a balloon. But he wanted his picture on a scarf like that.

In the light of the handicap principle, familiar events took on a different complexion. When Ted Turner decided in 1997 to give $1 billion to the United Nations, was it solely for the good of the planet? Or did he intuitively understand the less-is-more logic of the handicap principle? "I have learned," he said, "the more good that I did, the more money comes in." And in fact he has only gotten richer since announcing his gift. Moreover, his handicap display apparently influenced a rival Turner had criticized by name in the course of announcing his gift. Formerly a philanthropic skinflint, Bill Gates has subsequently gone out of his way to dwarf Turner's gift, donating more than $23 billion to his own charitable foundation. Both men are thus seriously out of pocket. But by the upside-down mathematics of the handicap principle, they are infinitely richer in status, the real currency of Darwinian fitness.

Zahavi, when I left him, was back in the desert among his babblers. To show me how the babblers respond to predators, he'd buried a model of a viper so only the eyes and nostrils were visible through the sand. The first bird to spot it cried, "EEE-EEE-EEE," and fanned out its wings. Then, instead of backing away, the bird stepped to within a few inches of the viper's fangs and began to circle it ritually, one wing held out like a bullfighter's cape, with an air of insouciance. "The best bullfighter is relaxed," said Zahavi, stretching out his own arm as if it held a cape. "As soon as the bull passes, he knows it will take five or six seconds to turn and attack from the rear. And what does he do with these five or six seconds? He lifts his arm, the opposite of being concerned. And then at the last second, he turns with the cape and tricks the bull." Zahavi lifted his own arms and turned as if accepting the acclaim of the crowd. At his feet, another babbler stepped up and took a turn to dance in front of the viper. Zahavi began to mull over some minor quirk in its behavior, adjusting the nuances of his handicap principle to accommodate every new observation.

"Tomorrow," he said, with an air of confidence, "I will be a little more certain of the details."

Richard Dawkins changes his mind on the "Handicap Principle"

Richard Dawkins on "The Handicap Princple"




John Brockman's Edge site celebrates each New Year with a question, posed to a list of contributors. This year, the question is "What have you changed your mind about? Why?"
http://www.edge.org/q2008/q08_index.html
This essay is my answer to the question. The version posted on 
Edge is considerably shortened, to conform to the norms of the anthology. It also has a different title, the one used here being the generic title of the whole symposium.


When a politician changes his mind, he is a 'flip-flopper.' Politicians will do almost anything to disown the virtue — as some of us might see it — of flexibility. Margaret Thatcher said, "The lady is not for turning." Tony Blair said, "I don't have a reverse gear." Leading Democratic Presidential candidates, whose original decision to vote in favour of invading Iraq had been based on information believed in good faith but now known to be false, 
still stand by their earlier error for fear of the dread accusation: 'flip-flopper'. How very different is the world of science. Scientists actually gain kudos through changing their minds. If a scientist cannot come up with an example where he has changed his mind during his career, he feels the need to apologize. He is suspected of betraying the spirit of science. He is hidebound, rigid, inflexible, dogmatic! It is not really all that paradoxical, when you think about it, that prestige in politics and science should push in opposite directions. I'll take it no further than just to point it out, with a whiff of irony.

I have changed my mind, as it happens, about a highly paradoxical theory of prestige, in my own field of evolutionary biology. That theory is the Handicap Principle suggested by the Israeli zoologist Amotz Zahavi. I used to think it was nonsense, and I said so in my first book, 
The Selfish Gene. In the Second Edition I changed my mind, as the result of some brilliant theoretical modelling by my Oxford colleague Alan Grafen.

Zahavi's evolutionary theory of prestige was anticipated in the human sphere by the economist Thorstein Veblen. Anthropologists had drawn attention to 'Potlatch' ceremonies, whereby rival chieftains compete by means of conspicuous displays of ruinous generosity. You demonstrate your wealth and power by ostentatious donation or waste, culminating, in extreme cases, by setting fire to everything you possess. Veblen developed the idea in his concept of Conspicuous Consumption. Individuals consume goods not because they want them but in order to demonstrate status. Zahavi's version is evolutionary, and therefore assumed to be not consciously thought-out by its animal practitioners. But it comes to the same thing.

Zahavi originally proposed his Handicap Principle in the context of sexual advertisement by male animals to females. The long tail of a cock pheasant is a handicap. It endangers the male's own survival. Other theories of sexual selection reasoned - plausibly enough - that the long tail is favoured in 
spite of its being a handicap. Zahavi's maddeningly contrary suggestion was that females prefer long tailed males, not in spite of the handicap but precisely because of it. To use Zahavi's own preferred style of anthropomorphic whimsy, the male pheasant is saying to the female, "Look what a fine pheasant I must be, for I have survived in spite of lugging this incapacitating burden around behind me." For Zahavi, the handicap has to be a genuine one, authentically costly. A fake burden - the equivalent of the padded shoulder as counterfeit of physical strength - would be rumbled by the females. In Darwinian terms, natural selection would favour females who scorn padded males and choose instead males who demonstrate genuine physical strength in a costly, and therefore, unfakeable way. For Zahavi, cost is paramount. The male has to pay a genuine cost, or females would be selected to favour a rival male who does so.

Zahavi generalized his theory from sexual selection to all spheres in which animals communicate with one another. He himself studies Arabian Babblers, little brown birds of communal habit, who often 'altruistically' feed each other. Conventional 'selfish gene' theory would seek an explanation in terms of kin selection or reciprocation. Indeed, such explanations are usually right (I haven't changed my mind about that). But Zahavi noticed that the most generous babblers are the socially dominant individuals, and he interpreted this in handicap terms. Translating, as ever, from bird to human language, he put it into the mouth of a donor bird like this: "Look how superior I am to you, I can even afford to give you food." Similarly, some individuals act as 'sentinels', sitting conspicuously in a high tree and not feeding, watching for hawks and warning the rest of the flock who are therefore able to get on with feeding. Again eschewing kin selection and other manifestations of conventional selfish genery, Zahavi's explanation followed his own paradoxical logic: "Look what a great bird I am, I can afford to risk my life sitting high in a tree watching out for hawks, saving your miserable skins for you and allowing you to feed while I don't." What the sentinel pays out in personal cost he gains in social prestige, which translates into reproductive success. Natural selection favours conspicuous and costly generosity: favours handicaps because they are handicaps.

When Zahavi first explained the Handicap Principle to me, I voiced my scepticism with a 
reductio ad absurdum. Should we then expect, I demanded sarcastically, that natural selection will favour animals with only one leg and only one eye? Amotz's retort was witty enough, even then, to give me pause. "Some of our best generals," that former Israeli soldier reminded me, "have only one eye."

You can see why I was sceptical. It is all very well to pay a high cost to gain social prestige; maybe the raised prestige does indeed translate into Darwinian fitness; but the cost itself still has to be paid, and that will wipe out the fitness gain. Don't evade the issue by saying that the cost is only 
partial and will onlypartially wipe out the fitness gain. After all, won't a rival individual come along and out-compete you in the prestige stakes by paying a greater cost? And won't the cost therefore escalate until the point where it exactly wipes out the alleged fitness gain?

Verbal arguments of this kind can take us only so far. Mathematical models are needed, and various people supplied them, notably John Maynard Smith who concluded that Zahavi's idea, though interesting, just wouldn't work. Or, to be more precise, Maynard Smith couldn't find a mathematical model that led to the conclusion that Zahavi's theory might work. He left open the possibility that somebody else might come along later with a better model. That is exactly what Alan Grafen did, and now we all have to change our minds.

I translated Grafen's mathematical model back into words, in the Second Edition of 
The Selfish Gene (pp 309-313), and I shall not repeat myself here but will summarise the essence as a four stage argument. I'll use the convention that males are advertising to females, but it can be generalised to any cases where individuals are advertising to other individuals about anything.

1. Males really do vary in quality, and females really would benefit by choosing high quality males.

2. Each male is privy to some information about his own quality which is not directly available to anybody else. What is available to females is the advertisements that males choose to offer, which may or may not be truthful indications of their quality.

3. We can imagine all possible 'strategies' of advertisement that males might offer. For example one strategy might be complete honesty: perfect positive correlation between genuine quality and strength of advertisement. Another strategy might be the exact opposite: perfect dishonesty, or a negative correlation between quality and strength of advertisement. A third strategy might be a poker faced refusal to vouchsafe any information at all: zero correlation between quality and strength of advertisement. Mathematically, we can imagine all possible functions relating strength of advertisement to quality. Mathematically, we imagine a population of males adopting the full range of possible advertising strategies.

4. Females, exposed to male advertisements, also could adopt a wide range of strategies. One strategy might be total credulity: perfect positive correlation between strength of male advertisement and female preference. Another strategy might be the exact opposite: perfect negative correlation between strength of male advertisement and female preference. As with the male strategies, mathematically we imagine all possible functions relating strength of male advertisement to female responsiveness.

Grafen now set himself the task of discovering a pair of strategies, one male and one female, which were mutually stable, in Maynard Smith's sense of evolutionary stability ('ESS'). An evolutionarily stable male strategy is one such that, when all males adopt it, no male gains by doing anything different. An evolutionarily stable female strategy is one such that, when all females adopt it, no female gains by doing anything different. Grafen sought a pair of stable strategies, one stable within males and one stable within females, which remained stable in the presence of each other. He did indeed find such a mutual ESS and he was then able to examine its properties. They turned out to be thoroughly Zahavian! As follows:

1. At ESS, out of the whole range of possible display strategies, males will choose the honest strategy: correctly display your true quality, 
even if this betrays that your quality is poor.

2. At ESS, out of the whole range of credulity-incredulity strategies, females will chose the total credulity strategy: choose the male who advertises the highest quality.

3. At ESS, out of the full range of advertisements that males might choose, the advertisements that they actually will choose are costly. The advertising rule that is chosen at ESS is chosen precisely because it has the effect of lowering the fitness of the advertiser, all other things being equal.

4. At ESS, advertising is more costly to lower quality males. A given level of advertising strength damages a low quality male more than a high quality male. Low quality males incur a more serious risk from costly advertising than high quality males.

These ESS outcomes are full-bloodedly Zahavian. In a brilliant feat of theoretical biology, Alan Grafen has shown that we must all change our minds. I still find it quite worrying that we have to do so, because the idea seems so counter-intuitive. Of course Grafen has not shown that animal displays are always Zahavian. But he has shown that the main theoretical 
objection to the handicap principle was wrong. I should repeat, by the way, that my use of 'male' and 'female' was a convention for ease of exposition. You could go right through my explanation, substituting 'sentinel babbler' for male and 'feeding babbler' for female. Indeed, with a few adjustments to the explanation, you could go right back to humans and the advertising industry.

A word of caution, to end. Grafen's role in this story is of the utmost importance. Zahavi advanced a wildly paradoxical and implausible idea, which — as Grafen was able to show — eventually turned out to be right. We must not fall into the trap of thinking that therefore, the next time somebody comes up with a wildly paradoxical and implausible idea, that one too will turn out to be right. Most implausible ideas are implausible for a good reason. Zahavi eventually found his Grafen. Most proponents of wildly implausible ideas will not. Although I was wrong in my scepticism, and I have now changed my mind, I was still right to have been sceptical in the first place! We need our sceptics, and we need our Grafens to go to the trouble of proving them wrong.

Zahavian Mating Examples

Economist Thorstein Veblen and anthropologist studied "The Potlatch" ceremonies performed by tribes of pacific northwest coast. The ceremonies revolve around ruinous displays of generosity by rival chieftain. Extreme cases of these ceremonies lead to the burning of everything that the chieftain owns. Social status is considered enhanced by such displays which at times are extremely costly to the individual. These ceremonies and the yearning for social status and prestige point towards the "handicap principle" proposed by Amotz Zahavi.

Similarly a peacock with a longer and more colorful tail is always found to be more attractive by females although the handicap of supporting a longer tail comes at enormous cost to the peacock itself. Supporting a longer tail and still managing to survive and outwit one's predators is considered a sign of superior abilities.

Arabian babblers display handicaps by feeding other babblers altruistically. Some babblers sit atop tall trees as lookout sentinels making themselves visible to predators. The risk their lives for the babbler community and signal to the other members of their superior social status. The social status comes at considerable risk and in return are considered more suitable for reproduction.

Children crying when hungry expose themselves to danger by saying that my parents don't care for me so my predators should eat me. They are in effect handicapping both the parents and themselves. Most attempted suicides are also cases of handicapping. Lovers rarely succeed in attempting suicide.

Women with larger breasts also handicap themselves to show better reproductive abilities thereby attracting males to them. Although technically larger breasts don't correlate with better reproductive systems, but carrying around weight and surviving points out to other traits that might be more suitable for survival.

Problem with the Handicap Principle


The argument suffers as evolution would start supporting handicaps. The individual with more handicaps would always be more reproductive thereby increasing future probabilities of even more handicaps. After successive generations, the specie would only increase its handicaps and decrease its chances of survival by being eliminated by its competitor with lesser handicaps.

Handicap Principle proved right by mathematical modeling


Alan Grafen constructed a theoretical model where both females and males came up with different strategies in choosing a mate. The stability was achieved only when the male used an honest signaling strategy where as the signaling itself was able to differentiate between high quality and low quality males. Although having a longer tale is costly to the male peacock but it is not as costly to a superior quality male compared to a low quality male. The low quality male would suffer more compared to the high quality male if it has a longer tale.

If the tale in subsequent generation becomes longer, then the tale would become costly to even high quality males hence the signaling used should only be costly to low quality males but not to high quality male. If the tail becomes too long then the individual would be wiped out because of the cost and the tail would not be able to differentiate between high quality and low quality males. Hence a stable tail size would emerge.

The Human Handicap : ALTRUISM


The human handicap is altruism. But only rich men should practice being altruistic as being altruistic is not costly to the richer individual. Rich ugly guys with hot beautiful super models is normal. Vice versa, rich beautiful women with poor ugly guys is abnormal. The "Potlatch" ceremonies would therefore differentiate between chiefs who are genuinely altruistic from the ones who are faking it by literally wiping out the fake altruistic chief.

Social status is therefore important as evolution is driven by it. Adapting signals which would differentiate qualities of male is also important. The signal should be costly to lower quality males only

  1. earn lots of money
  2. spend and give away money as long as it is not costly to you
  3. help out other people
  4. have a muscular physique. (lower quality males would have to work harder in the gym compared to naturally muscular individuals)
  5. always be well dressed
  6. your car and house
  7. having finesse, work less and produce more
  8. wasting time partying and travelling but still earning more
  9. risky behavior during courtship. Making the first move.
  10. Bull fighting
If there are anymore suggestions then please add your comments

Thursday, October 28, 2010

Zahavian Mating

The handicap principle is a hypothesis originally proposed in 1975 by biologist Amotz Zahavi[1][2][3] to explain how evolution may lead to "honest" or reliablesignaling between animals who have an obvious motivation to bluff or deceive each other. The handicap principle suggests that reliable signals must be costly to the signaler, costing the signaler something that could not be afforded by an individual with less of a particular trait. For example, in the case of sexual selection, the theory suggests that animals of greater biological fitness signal this status through handicapping behaviour or morphology that effectively lowers this quality. The central idea is that sexually selected traits function like conspicuous consumption, signalling the ability to afford to squander a resource simply by squandering it. Receivers know that the signal indicates quality because inferior quality signallers cannot afford to produce such wastefully extravagant signals.


The generality of the phenomenon is the matter of some debate and disagreement, and Zahavi's views on the scope and importance of handicaps in biology remain outside the mainstream.[4] Nevertheless, the idea has been very influential,[5][6][7] with most researchers in the field believing that the theory explains some aspects of animal communication.


So, Next time you want to impress a girl then do something which could potentially be really costly to you. Examples are singing, dancing, bungee jumping, muscular physique etc. Doing something which could potentially be costly or doing something which is actually costly like buying a ferrari would make you look attractive. Girls want you to make the first move, so the cost of getting rejected would be born by you. Risky and costly moves represent that you have other qualities which are better than the others even after living on the edge and surviving.